Did Prince Oberyn Kill the Mountain?
The question of whether Prince Oberyn Martell, a character from George R.R. Martin’s epic fantasy series “A Song of Ice and Fire,” killed the Mountain has been a topic of debate among fans for years. Prince Oberyn, also known as the Red Viper, is infamous for his cunning, charm, and brute strength. The Mountain, Gregor Clegane, is a massive and fearsome warrior, known for his loyalty to House Lannister. This article aims to delve into the evidence and theories surrounding this controversial topic.
In the series, Prince Oberyn has a notorious history of raping and killing women. His character is portrayed as a hedonistic and brutal figure, which is part of his appeal. In the second season of the television adaptation, “Game of Thrones,” Prince Oberyn has the opportunity to kill the Mountain during a trial by combat. The Mountain had been charged with raping Elia Martell, Oberyn’s sister. Oberyn takes the opportunity to confront the Mountain and, after a brutal battle, ends up killing him.
However, some fans argue that Oberyn did not actually kill the Mountain. They believe that Oberyn, who was known for his cunning and manipulative nature, orchestrated the entire situation to his advantage. The trial by combat was a perfect setup for Oberyn to eliminate a rival and assert his dominance. Furthermore, some fans argue that the Mountain, being a giant, could have been killed by a fall, rather than by Oberyn’s sword.
Another theory suggests that Oberyn’s death at the hands of the Mountain was not an accident. In the books, it is revealed that Oberyn had been poisoned by his sister, Elia, who wanted to ensure her brother’s death. Some fans believe that Elia arranged for the Mountain to kill Oberyn as part of her plan to avenge their family’s honor.
In conclusion, whether Prince Oberyn killed the Mountain or not remains a subject of debate. The evidence is inconclusive, and the truth may never be fully known. The debate itself is a testament to the complexity and depth of George R.R. Martin’s world-building and character development.
Now, let’s see what the fans have to say about this topic:
1. “I think Oberyn killed the Mountain. He was too cunning to let that chance slip away.”
2. “The Mountain would have killed Oberyn in a heartbeat. The idea that Oberyn killed him is preposterous.”
3. “Oberyn might have orchestrated the whole thing, but he still ended up dead. It’s all part of the game of thrones.”
4. “I believe Oberyn was poisoned. The Mountain never had a chance.”
5. “I think the Mountain just fell on his sword. Oberyn had no need to kill him.”
6. “It’s a mystery. Martin never said for sure.”
7. “Oberyn’s death was just a part of his larger plan. He would never have wasted that chance.”
8. “The Mountain was too strong. Oberyn couldn’t have killed him.”
9. “I think Oberyn killed the Mountain to prove a point. He was never a hero.”
10. “The Mountain had no reason to kill Oberyn. He was just defending himself.”
11. “Oberyn was too smart to fight the Mountain head-on. He must have had a plan.”
12. “I think the Mountain was just tired. He couldn’t have kept up with Oberyn.”
13. “Oberyn’s death was just a twist. Martin loves to keep us guessing.”
14. “I think Oberyn was killed by the Mountain. He underestimated the giant.”
15. “The Mountain had a grudge against Oberyn. He would have taken his revenge.”
16. “Oberyn might have killed the Mountain, but he ended up paying for it.”
17. “The Mountain was too powerful. Oberyn had no chance.”
18. “I think Oberyn and the Mountain were both acting. It was all part of a bigger game.”
19. “The Mountain was a brute, but Oberyn was a genius. I believe Oberyn had a plan.”
20. “It’s a tough call. I can’t decide who really killed who.
